Will the ATO Pay for Its Mistakes?
I brought up the deeply distressing case of Mr Jae Jang, highlighting striking similarities to the Clarke case. I noted that after years of protracted legal battles, criminal charges against Mr Jang and his employees were dropped because the prosecution had no evidence to offer. I pointed out the devastating human toll — Mr Jang spending time in jail and his sister dying by suicide after her bank accounts were falsely frozen by the ATO— leading me to state that the ATO has blood on its hands, and asking whether these cases reflect a broader pattern of behaviour. Ms Owen confirmed she had concluded a review of Mr Jang's case, finding some of his allegations substantiated, and noted she is now conducting a systemic review examining whether historical issues like bias or prejudice in decision-making could still happen under current protocols, with a report due to be published the following month. I pointed out that systems drive behaviour, noting that unlike in the United States where investigation and prosecution are separated, the ATO handles both, creating an institutional incentive not to drop flawed cases. Ms Owen observed that the ATO does implement some separation of duties between audits and criminal investigations, which her inquiry was also examining. I then asked if she saw parallels between these cases and the robodebt scandal, specifically regarding the ATO providing unreliable data, though Ms Owen viewed them as separate. While she acknowledged that both the Clarke and Jang cases resulted in major financial, emotional, and business harm, she clarified that her investigation found no direct causal link between the ATO's actions and Ms Jang's tragic death, though she strongly criticised the ATO's failure to acknowledge notification of her passing for five years. When I asked if the commissioner would give undertakings to compensate Mr Clarke and Mr Jang, Ms Owen stated that compensation is outside her remit and a matter for the commissioner. Finally, I asked whether the Jang and Clarke cases add weight to the Falinski inquiry recommendations, particularly regarding shifting the burden of proof from the taxpayer to the ATO, to which she replied that it was a policy matter outside her remit. Transcript: https://www.malcolmrobertsqld.com.au/will-the-ato-pay-for-its-mistakes/
Suggested videos

The Public Arrest Spectacle: Who Really Made the Call?
Malcolm Roberts · 1:43

Will the ATO Pay for Its Mistakes? The Watchdog Said 'Outside My Remit' When Asked
Aussie Pulse · 5:38

‘People haven’t heard of him’: Malcolm Roberts is One Nation’s ‘main liability’
News24 · 6:33

Malcolm Torches the ATO Over Costly Mistakes: Will Taxpayers Finally Get Paid?
The Financial Express · 9:35

COVID INQUIRY UNDER FIRE: Malcolm Roberts Demands Answer
The Financial Express · 10:26

5 Bookkeeping Mistakes That Can Get You in Trouble With The ATO
The Bookkeeping Channel · 5:22

DEBUNKED: Brian Cox & Senator Malcolm Roberts on QandA
Malcolm Roberts · 42:02

ATO payment plans: what to do if you cannot pay your tax debt | Bradley Witham
Bradley Witham | Australian Tax Tips · 3:32

Weekly Wrap-up with Senator Malcolm Roberts
Malcolm Roberts · 1:12:57

The ATO is cracking down on these 6 payroll mistakes
Davie Mach · 8:43

Whole Parliament In SHAMBL£S After Malcolm Roberts Gives Labor F!NAL WARN!NG And Goes Off!
Australian Decode · 12:43

ATO Issues New SMSF Trustee Guidance
Manoj Abichandani · 1:01